Recession Indicators Turned Green. Job Quality Hasn’t.

recession

October’s jobs report pushed the headline recession indicators back to green, but “labor hoarding” explains why the earnings boom still isn’t reaching full-time workers.

key-takeaways

Here is the puzzle investors face right now. S&P 500 companies are on track to report 31.4% earnings growth for the third quarter, the eighth straight quarter of double-digit gains. Last Friday, the October jobs report beat every forecast, with payrolls up 165,000 and unemployment back down to 4.1%. On the surface, the recession indicators have turned green. Beneath the surface, the quality of the jobs tells a different story. Such is the question worth answering: is the labor market healing, or are companies still “hoarding” labor while profits do the heavy lifting?

Why The Recession Indicators Disagree

Let’s start with the economic indicators that say all is well. In the most recent reports:

  • Initial jobless claims fell to 189,000 in the week ended October 31, the lowest reading since 1969.
  • The Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey (JOLTS), which printed a layoff rate of 1.0% in September, near the floor of its 25-year history
  • The October payrolls rose 165,000 against a consensus near 65,000, and revisions added 84,000 jobs to August and September.

In other words, if your only recession indicators are layoffs, claims, and the headline payroll count, there is no recession anywhere in sight.

Now look at the other half of the labor data. The JOLTS hiring rate sits at 3.4%, in line with its 2013 average and well below the 3.9% pace of 2019. The number of people working part-time because they can’t find full-time work jumped by 339,000 in October to 4.8 million. Workers unemployed for six months or longer now make up 27.6% of the unemployed. Average hourly earnings grew 3.1% from a year earlier, still short of the 3.7% inflation rate.