Fully Invested Bear

“If you put a gun to my head, I really wouldn’t be short a Dow stock!”

The source of that firm declaration is an old friend of ours, a crack (read; very rich) money manager and someone who passionately embraces anonymity (never quoted, never wrong). We put a gun to his head, he refused to short any of the Dow 30 stocks, but lucky for him, neither gun nor we were loaded.

What makes our friend’s unequivocal statement noteworthy is that he has the most profound distrust of this great bull market, calls it “ridiculous, absurdly overvalued,” thinks we’re in the process of putting a top in it, warns that “we’re living on borrowed time.” And yet he see the possibility of the Dow Jones Industrials getting as high as 9000 later this year, as more and more money flows into fewer and fewer stocks, all of which happen to be in the Dow.

He expects a correction at some point during the year – the third quarter seems as good a time as any for it – and a violent one. But his plan is to buy the break in anticipation that the final, climactic advance will carry through the end of the year, maybe into 1998.

If Dow Jones should decide to sanction a derivatives index on the D-J Industrials – on which we have no word and less knowledge – then our friend thinks the Industrials are a “moon shot.” But that would also signal to him “the top tick” in the market, comparable to the beginning of the end of Japan’s big bull market in 1989, when trading in the Nikkei 225 futures began in the spring and options in the fall. The market, of course, peaked in December.

For all his demonstrated prowess and astuteness as an investor, we should caution that he’s a trader by heart, and his ability to turn on a dime is one of the big reasons he has so many dollars. Still, we feel his speculations are worth passing along. First, because he has been so successful and for so many years, but also because he’s an unlikely and sophisticated example of that increasingly familiar phenomenon in the market: the fully invested bear.

. . . Up & Down Wall Street, by Alan Abelson, Barron’s (May 5, 1997)

Alan Abelson’s prose is just as appropriate today as when it was first scribed in 1997 for there are currently a bunch of fully invested bears. We recalled the quip from our departed friend Alan Abelson when we read a quote from what we believe to be a fully invested bear, namely Carl Icahn, who cautioned last week about the “euphoric state” of the stock market. Shortly thereafter the good folks at Credit Suisse came out with a report warning of an equity market meltdown in 2018. Meanwhile, the portfolio managers (PMs) we talk to at such organizations are indeed “fully invested!”

So, we are now in the ebullient month of December and as often stated, “It is tough to put stocks away to the downside in December. It can happen, but it’s pretty rare.” In fact, there were only two years that saw negative returns for the S&P 500 (SPX/2642.22) in December. They were 1936 and 1955, but even then the declines were small. To be sure, over the last 100 years the average December gain has been 1.55% with a “win rate” of 74% of the time (Chart 1). Moreover, ten of the S&P’s macro sectors have experienced positive returns in December. As Bespoke Investment Group notes, “Surprisingly, it has been the high yielding dividend paying sectors that have seen the largest gains with Real Estate, Telecom Services, and Utilities all posting gains of more than 2%.” Worth mention is that last December ALL the macro sectors rallied! Parsing a list of some of the historically best performing stocks in the S&P 500 during the month of December we find the following names from the Raymond James research universe. Each stock screens well on our models and carries a favorable rating from our fundamental analysts: Broadcom (AVGO/$271.56/Strong Buy), Oracle (ORCL/$49.61/Outperform), Valero (VLO/$84.17/Outperform), Red Hat (RHT/$125.26/Outperform), Nvidia (NVDA/$197.68/Outperform), and Mohawk (MHK/$284.82/Strong Buy).