Who Pays the Government’s Bills?

Who Pays the Government’s Bills?

Why We Pay Taxes at All
A Short History of the Income Tax
What Taxes We Pay Today
Who Pays the Income Tax
Inside the Top 1%
Everyone Else
Who Pays All Federal Taxes, and Who Gets Help
Tulsa, Las Vegas, Cleveland and New York

"Taxes are what we pay for civilized society."

- Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.

"The art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to obtain the largest possible amount of feathers with the smallest possible amount of hissing."

- Attributed to Jean-Baptiste Colbert

As I noted last week, less than 1/10 of 1% of all the political ads this midterm election even mentioned the debt. The Congressional Budget Office projects our current almost $41 trillion debt to grow to $46 trillion by 2030. And that’s with no new spending, just the laws on the current books.

To use a horseracing analogy, we are rounding the turn and entering the home stretch of what will become a major sovereign debt crisis. To get an understanding of what that means for us as individuals in the country, we need to understand how we got here. And what it will take to resolve the crisis. There are many factors that will come into play, and we will need to look at them all.

For the next several letters we are going to talk about money and taxes: how much the federal government collects, from whom, what it spends, and what it would take to keep the debt from swallowing us. I want to start with the part almost everyone has an opinion about and almost no one (except for my readers!) has examined closely. Who actually pays the taxes in this country?

In fiscal year 2026, which ended September 30, Washington took in $5.4 trillion and spent $7.4 trillion. The deficit was just under $2 trillion. That is about 6.2% of GDP, and net interest on the debt crossed $1 trillion for the first time, about $1.1 trillion depending on how you count it, which is more than we spend on defense. Debt held by the public is now roughly 100% of GDP and approximately $33 trillion. Including debt that we “owe to ourselves” total US debt is about 123% and roughly $41 trillion.

We are not in a recession. Unemployment is low. Even with all the volatility, the overall stock market is near all-time highs. Interest rates have risen back to pre-GFC levels. This is what "normal" looks like now.

Over the course of this series, I am going to argue that the way out is to get the deficit below the growth rate of nominal GDP, so that the debt shrinks relative to the size of the economy. Do that, and we can grow our way out over time. Shrink the deficit further and we get there faster. In later letters we will get precise about what that target means. For now, just hold onto the idea that the gap we have to close is something like $1 trillion a year and growing, even though total deficits are in the $2 trillion range.

So how do we get there? You can either increase taxes, cut spending or a combination of both. That’s it. So how do we do it?

Whenever this subject comes up, there are many who say the answer is simple: tax the rich. It is a great slogan. It polls well. And I want to be fair about it, because there is a real case that people at the top can pay more. But slogans are not arithmetic. Before we can talk about how much more anyone should pay, we need to know who is paying now, and how much. That is what this letter is about. Next week, or perhaps the week after, we will ask the harder question: if we tried to close the gap with tax increases alone, how high would rates have to go, and what would that do to the economy?

Fair warning: there are a lot of tables and charts in this one. I think you will find some of them surprising. I certainly did.

See more: After the Midterms: High Expectations and “Good Gridlock”