Strong But Concentrated Economic Growth

strong-growth

The strength of the US economy during the third quarter was hardly a surprise. We expected economic growth of 3.5%, and the first estimate came in only slightly below that at a 3.4% quarter-over-quarter, seasonally adjusted annualized rate. Consumer spending and investment tied to the AI and data center buildout remained the primary drivers of growth. However, the conflict with Iran also had a larger-than-expected impact on economic activity. Federal defense spending increased 11.7% during the quarter while nondefense spending surged 22.2%. As a result, government consumption and investment rose 5.3% after edging down 0.1% in the second quarter.

As we have argued repeatedly in previous reports, consumer demand remains the backbone of the US economy. Not only does it account for roughly 70% of GDP, but it is also the most stable component of economic activity. The investment component, however, is a different story. Although smaller than consumption, it is significantly more volatile and often plays a central role in economic downturns. When investors turn cautious, what John Maynard Keynes called "animal spirits" can weaken, leading to slower investment and, ultimately, slower economic growth.

See more: Is AI Crowding Out the Rest of the Economy?

This is where our concern lies.

Financial markets often assume that today's growth trends will continue indefinitely. Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan famously described this tendency as irrational exuberance. We are not suggesting that current conditions resemble the periods Greenspan had in mind. Nevertheless, the remarkable performance of the stock market, combined with the outsized contribution of AI- and data center-related spending to overall investment and GDP growth, deserves attention.


manufacturing-vs-info

As the graph above shows, information processing equipment has made an extraordinary contribution to real private fixed investment growth since early 2025. In the third quarter alone, it accounted for slightly more than half of total real private fixed investment growth.