Investing in commodities can be a tempting but difficult path for investors who react impulsively to market headlines and short-term price movements. The temptation to chase recent market performance is a common pitfall for many investors, and it’s a mistake that may be particularly costly in the volatile world of commodities.
Chasing past returns can lead to poor decisions, as the commodities market is driven by fundamental supply and demand dynamics, not by momentum. A better approach, as discussed during VettaFi’s Alternatives Symposium on July 31, may be to ignore the hype and focus on the fundamental role commodities play in a diversified portfolio.
Kathy Kriskey, head of alternatives product strategy at Invesco
“The biggest mistake that investors make is chasing a commodity market," Kathy Kriskey, head of alternatives product strategy at Invesco, said during the symposium. “Commodities are volatile. They can move up; they're also going to move down.”
Recent history provides examples of this pitfall. During the Russian invasion of Ukraine, investors rushed to buy wheat, driving prices up. However, the market quickly corrected when it became clear there was sufficient wheat supply. Similarly, during the brief Iran/Israel conflict, investors frantically pursued crude oil, causing rapid price fluctuations, according to Kriskey.
Robert Minter, director of ETF investment strategy at Aberdeen Investments
Robert Minter, director of ETF investment strategy at Aberdeen Investments, emphasized the inherent volatility of commodities. "Commodities are usually the cause of surprise inflation," he said, highlighting that knee-jerk reactions can lead to significant investment errors.
Disciplined Approach to Commodities
Kriskey recommends a more measured approach: "It's better when you invest in commodities when they're not in the news, and hold them to hedge inflation, uncertainty, or provide diversification." This strategy requires patience and a long-term perspective, rather than emotional trading based on current events.
The unpredictability of commodity markets makes timing particularly challenging. Minter said agricultural commodities demonstrate this volatility perfectly. He cited a time when trade tensions prompted China to stop buying U.S. soybeans, causing producers to redirect crops to Brazil and Argentina, ultimately creating complex market dynamics that individual investors cannot easily anticipate.
Instead of chasing performance, experts recommend a strategic approach.
Kriskey suggests investors consider broad-based commodity ETFs like the Invesco Optimum Yield Diversified Commodity Strategy No K-1 ETF (PDBC), which provide diversified exposure across different commodity sectors. This approach helps mitigate the risks associated with focusing on a single commodity's short-term performance.
Minter adds that commodities can serve valuable portfolio functions, including diversification and low correlation with other asset classes. The key is understanding commodities as a strategic allocation, not a quick return driver.
Aberdeen offers the abrdn Bloomberg All Commodity Strategy K-1 Free ETF (BCI) and the abrdn Bloomberg All Commodity Longer Dated Strategy K-1 Free ETF (BCD) as broad commodity ETFs.
Investors may benefit by resisting the urge to chase commodity market trends. Developing a disciplined, diversified approach that positions commodities as a long-term portfolio component rather than a speculative investment opportunity may offer value.
A message from Advisor Perspectives and VettaFi: To learn more about this and other topics, check out some of our videos.
Read more commentaries by VettaFi | Advisor Perspectives
