Patiently Pausing

In his post-FOMC press conference on December 19, Fed Chairman Powell said that low inflation would allow the Fed to be more patient in adjusting rates. The stock market fell. He said essential the same thing in his January 30 press conference. The market rallied. Okay, that’s an over-simplification. The Fed’s tone has shifted, but not because of the stock market or pressure from the White House. The baseline economic outlook hasn’t changed much since mid-December. However, cross-currents and downside risks have increased. The employment report would suggest that the Fed might have more work to do in achieving its soft landing, but come on – it’s January. The bigger test for the job market will come in the spring. Over time, it will become apparent whether this current phase is merely a pause or the end of the Fed’s tightening cycle.

As expected, the Federal Open Market Committee removed the phrase suggesting “some further gradual increases” in the federal funds rate would likely be required. Expectations of rate increases had already been dampened in December, with senior Fed officials divided on whether there would be zero, one, or two rate hikes in 2018. We won’t get a new dot plot until March 20, but it’s likely that the dots will drift a little lower.

In his January 30 press conference, Powell noted that “the economy is in a good place.” The job picture “continues to be strong,” and “inflation remains near our 2% goal.” However, “despite the positive outlook, we have seen some cross-currents and conflicting signals about the outlook.” He cited slower growth abroad, “particularly China and Europe.” Financial conditions “tightened considerably in late 2018, and remain less supportive of growth than they were earlier in 2018.” In additions, some surveys of business and consumer sentiment moved lower, “giving reason for caution.” The cumulative effect of these developments “warrant a patient, wait-and-see approach regarding future policy changes.” The change in attitude “was not driven by a major shift in the baseline outlook for the economy,”Powell noted, “but the cross-currents suggest the risk of a less favorable outlook.” In addition, “the case for raising rates has weakened somewhat.”

The Fed also released guidance on the balance sheet. The Fed began to unwind its balance sheet in October 2017, allowing a certain portion of maturing Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities in its portfolio to roll off. The Fed increased the pace of the roll off over time. From the beginning, the Fed was a bit unsure of how the financial markets would react and where the process would end. Now it appears that the unwinding will end sooner, leaving the size of the balance sheet at a higher level than was expected several months ago, but Powell declined to say exactly when (that decision is coming). The FOMC also stressed the monetary policy will focus on maintaining ample reserves in the banking system. Reserves have been falling, but these are excess reserves – nothing to panic about. Moreover, it’s unclear why the balance sheet unwind would have such an asymmetrical impact on the financial markets compared to the buildup. That doesn’t make much sense, other than if the unwind is viewed with fear.

Scott Brown
Click here to enlarge