If only Europe could offer property investors the kind of buffet the US provides. For now, its listed real estate sector is fragmented and dysfunctional, the raison d’etre seemingly to create cheap takeover targets for buyout firms. But Europe could have real estate stocks that even US investors want to buy — and a sector that private equity firms can add to rather than shrink.
The transatlantic divide in real estate stocks is embarrassing. New York-listed Prologis Inc. is worth more than $100 billion. Its European logistics peer, Segro Plc, is worth £9 billion ($12 billion). The US has Realty Income Corp., a $50 billion company paying investors dividends from retail, leisure and even data center rents. Europe’s diversified plays, British Land Co. Plc and Land Securities Plc, have market values below £5 billion.
Many of the choicest assets are held out of the public markets. In 2017, Blackstone Inc. sold its Logicor logistics business to China Investment Corp. instead of doing an initial public offering. There’s a vicious circle. Lacking global relevance, the European sector withers further.
Stocks trade at big discounts to net tangible assets (the net worth of the company’s portfolio as assessed by independent valuers). So when a buyout bidder comes along to pay a 30% takeover premium on the share price, weary investors sell.
True, private equity was sidelined when interest rates soared in 2022. But as leveraged finance returned, so did deals. KKR & Co. and Stonepeak Partners LP last month agreed to buy Assura Plc, seeing off a rival offer from listed rival Primary Health Properties Plc. Blackstone Inc. recently made an indicative proposal to acquire Warehouse REIT Plc, underscoring its continued interest taking logistics companies private, although due diligence has led it to rethink the price.
Against that backdrop, two recent public-to-public deal situations seem significant. Belgium’s Aedifica SA is seeking an all-share takeover of healthcare-property peer Cofinimmo SA. The target has acknowledged the strategic logic of combining – it just wants sweeter terms. The firms have a combined market value of €6 billion ($7 billion). In the UK, acquisitive warehouse company LondonMetric Property Plc has secured a cash-and-shares deal to buy Urban Logistics Reit Plc.
The healthcare and logistics sectors may be attractive, but it’s pretty clear that the primary selling point of both these deals is more simple — scale and greater visibility to investors. LondonMetric’s transaction would solidify the stock’s place in the FTSE-100 index whereas now it loiters around the relegation zone.
What should happen next? Quite simply, more consolidation. The old chestnut – a combination of British Land and Land Securities – would create a single, diversified play offering exposure to prime London offices, retail parks, shopping malls and logistics assets. The idea’s been around for donkeys’ years, probably because it makes sense. But there are smaller rivals where the logic of huddling together is going to be even more beneficial.
The bankers’ fantasy would be M&A creating scale players in home markets, with a follow-on round of spinoffs and disposals. That could in turn establish cross-border European champions specializing in, say, office, retail, residential and logistics. In fact, there’s no need to go that far. Yes, real estate requires operational skill, which argues for specialization. However, the valuation benefits of specialization are unlikely to be as great as those from scale — savings on headquarters and listing costs, trading liquidity and global visibility. Better to be a large European firm with a bit of office and a bit of retail than a small but invisible student-housing specialist.
Continued uncertainty over the prospects for the office market and the risk of recession will dampen animal spirits. Just when white-collar workers are scaling back on homeworking, along comes the threat that AI will displace them entirely. Countering this is a favorable capital-markets dynamic that could now put real estate on investors’ radar. Firstly, the general pickup in European stocks. Secondly, an easing interest rate environment is supportive for the investor perception of the industry. Thirdly, while rents are vulnerable in a recession, the sector escapes direct tariff impacts.
European real estate CEOs aren’t going to benefit from any of this if they steward small, thinly traded stocks. The US is the world’s most successful market for real estate investment trusts. Europe needs to narrow the gap.
A message from Advisor Perspectives and VettaFi: To learn more about this and other topics, check out some of our webcasts.
Bloomberg News provided this article. For more articles like this please visit
bloomberg.com.
Read more articles by Chris Hughes
