

Insurance was once viewed as stable, predictable—maybe a bit boring. But over the past decade, insurers have been innovators across the balance sheet. There are new asset classes and strategies on the asset side, new products and funding structures on the liability side, and recently, new equity approaches. Understanding how this renaissance is happening is key to unlocking value.
To be sure, credit and equity investors have different priorities when evaluating insurers. But the views overlap more than they diverge. The question isn’t simply what an insurer owns or how fast it’s growing. It’s whether assets, liabilities and capital work together—and whether an insurance company’s management can explain its asset strategy with enough clarity to earn investors' trust.
See more: What Higher Interest Rates Are Telling Insurance Investors
Start by Evaluating the Whole Insurance Balance Sheet
Evaluating an insurer requires a holistic view: how much risk is an insurer already taking on its liabilities, and how much tolerance does that leave for risk on the asset side? We look at the ratings mix, the allocation to alternative investments and the exposure to more complex forms of private credit, especially those with the least transparency. The challenge is distinguishing productive specialization from excessive concentration, particularly when seemingly diverse investments become vulnerable to correlated losses.
Funding agreement-backed notes (FABNs), which enable insurers to raise money from investors with a set repayment date, illustrate the trade-offs. Because the liability is so certain, an insurer can arguably take on more uncertainty on its asset allocation. In theory, it could match these liabilities with investment-grade corporate bonds that repay all principal on a single date. At the same time, though, we think insurers should guard against becoming too reliant on these notes, because having too large a share of reserves tied to a single liability can create concentration risk in the eyes of rating agencies or investors.
In practice, however, public corporate bonds typically don’t earn enough above the funding cost to make the program work. Because repayment dates are known, insurers may instead take calculated risks. These can include buying securities that pay more because borrowers can repay early or purchasing more complex assets that could be repaid either sooner or later than expected, while still aiming to match incoming cash with payments coming due.
Size matters, too. Once these funding programs reach 25% to 30% of an insurer’s reserves, investors and rating agencies could get less comfortable. When large amounts are coming due at once, it creates rollover risk—the risk that an insurer can't replace the funding. Drawing on different funding sources can help, but it doesn’t eliminate the risks of borrowing too much. There’s no single right approach to matching investments with future payments, but insurers need to explain their approach clearly.
Look Beneath Broad Labels to Assess Investments
Insurance investments aren’t defined by high-level categories, so it’s critical to take a closer look at the details. Private credit, for example, isn’t a monolith. The term loosely covers a broad range of assets including investment-grade loans, sub-investment-grade loans to midsize companies and asset-based finance—lending backed by pools of assets such as equipment or consumer loans. Rather than penalizing broad buckets of private credit, it’s important to understand what’s underneath: Who originated the loans? What collateral backs them? Where does any credit enhancement, or extra mitigation against losses, come from?
The same granular analysis is needed for affiliated investments. These are assets an insurer acquires through related companies, such as an investment firm under the same corporate umbrella. Equity investors understand the benefits of some of these relationships, but they may have questions about governance. For example, are public shareholders being prioritized and how does the risk end up on the balance sheet? Affiliated investments aren’t universally good or bad. What matters is how they’re structured, how concentrated they are and how clearly they’re disclosed.
Transparency is Essential for Building Trust
As insurance structures become more sophisticated, investors are likely to have a more challenging time getting comfortable with what’s under the hood. That makes detailed disclosure by management vital. FABNs can be especially opaque, so management should be ready to explain how the insurer’s investments line up with its repayment obligations.
Disclosure matters to investors in different ways. Bond investors may demand a premium from insurers whose strategies look aggressive. But “aggressive” is often a matter of investor perception: the more disclosure they get, the more comfortable they often become. For stock investors, better disclosure hasn’t yet translated into higher valuation multiples, but it may offer more of a cushion on the downside of the next credit cycle. Trust in management teams is critical, and it’s bolstered if they’ve navigated a credit cycle before.
Look For Durable Growth and Constructive Oversight
On the growth side, trust in management dictates whether equity investors believe in a company’s growth strategy. In our view, growth should be self-funded and preserve healthy returns on invested capital. When an opportunity is large enough to require tapping capital markets for financing, we think there should be a clear payback period and a credible path to reasonable returns within five years.
When it comes to the regulatory dimension, equity markets often react negatively in the short term if new rules appear likely to constrain capital or growth. Given time, however, more scrutiny of financial engineering in areas like securitized assets, offshore reinsurance and ratings may strengthen confidence in the industry and support growth.
Collateralized loan obligations (CLOs) show how that scrutiny is playing out. In 2022, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), the group of US state insurance regulators, began reviewing how much capital insurers must hold against these securities backed by pools of corporate loans. The NAIC has announced that a new capital regime will take effect by year-end for broadly syndicated CLOs. With mortgage-backed securities and CLOs already addressed, asset-backed securities may be next on the docket.
Manage Emerging Risks Across Asset-Class Silos
When it comes to assessing insurance risks, AI and data centers show why looking at exposure by asset class, sector or CUSIP is no longer enough. For example, data center risk can appear in public and private corporate bonds, securitizations, infrastructure, REITs, commercial mortgages and alternatives. This makes it a thematic risk rather than a single-security or sector risk. About 4% of US life insurers’ bond purchases in the first half of 2026 went to identifiable data center investments—an encouraging starting point.
The question is where the trend goes from here and how insurers pace that exposure. Within the insurance industry, AI’s clearest benefits so far seem to be operational, such as automating processes and coding, trimming expenses, and strengthening cyber defense. Companies have moved past a throw-spaghetti-at-the-wall approach, and are now focused on returns, costs and dependence on AI providers.
In an Insurance Renaissance, Complexity Raises the Premium on Judgment
The renaissance in the insurance industry is creating meaningful opportunities. But it’s also producing greater complexity and increasing the need for disclosure. Investors should start with the perspective of the entire balance sheet, looking under the hood, and requiring improved disclosures. From our perspective, insurers that can reliably deliver moderate, durable growth and make a strong case for their approach to risk seem like the most compelling propositions.
The views expressed herein do not constitute research, investment advice or trade recommendations, do not necessarily represent the views of all AB portfolio-management teams and are subject to change over time.
A message from Advisor Perspectives and VettaFi: Discover something new! Click here to register for our upcoming webcasts.
© AllianceBernstein
Read more commentaries by AllianceBernstein