Value Stocks: The Cash-Flow Case for a Continuing Comeback

It’s easy to understand why investors are skeptical about value stocks. After nearly two decades of chronic weakness, value’s strong rebound since early 2025 hasn’t offered enough proof that the turnaround has staying power. Yet in our view, the market backdrop is shifting—and early signs strengthen the case for rebuilding exposure to value.

Value investing has a distinguished pedigree, but its reputation has been bruised. First articulated by Benjamin Graham and David Dodd nearly a century ago, the value philosophy rests on a simple insight: markets often overreact to uncertainty or disappointment. Using fundamental research, value investors seek to identify mispriced companies and capture recovery potential when market perceptions begin to change.

Read more: How Fixed-Income Investing Is Evolving for European Insurers

For the last 20 years, that discipline was tested. Value stocks thrived from 1980 through 2007, but after the global financial crisis (GFC), growth stocks have led, helped by low rates, abundant liquidity and technology-driven earnings growth. Value-stock discounts failed to revert to the mean as expected. Apart from a brief rebound after the COVID-19 pandemic, value persistently trailed growth (Display), and many actively managed value strategies struggled to keep pace.

Column chart shows MSCI World Value Index vs MSCI World Growth Index from 1980 through 2026, indicating when value outperformed or underperformed, annotated for major market events.