AI Downsides Dominate Discourse

At graduation ceremonies, audiences are often reminded to limit their audible reactions and hold applause, so that all graduates’ names can be heard. But a few viral videos this year showed a new disturbance to be managed: graduating students booing speakers if they extolled the virtues of artificial intelligence (AI).

This year has been marked by a shift in the perceptions of AI. The technology gained mainstream attention upon the public launch of ChatGPT in November 2022. For a few years thereafter, users explored the new capabilities, businesses set adoption strategies, and investors rewarded any firm with exposure to AI. But in the year to date, markets have grown nervous, security experts are on alert, communities are protesting, and students are rebelling.

New entrants to the labor force may see AI as competition, with good cause. Harvard University economists found a pronounced decline in junior-level job postings by firms who adopted AI, and for positions more exposed to AI. The trend emerged conspicuously in 2023 as ChatGPT took root.

share of respondents

Macro risks around AI are on the rise. Anthropic found that its latest model, Mythos 5, could identify software security vulnerabilities with a speed and precision that far exceeded any human hacker. The model was previewed for only select institutions for research into its security. Last week, the company launched a scaled-back version, Fable 5, but it, too, was taken offline on orders from the U.S. government when it showed potential as a cyber weapon. Other AI firms are sure to launch models that can be used similarly; defending against them will be a tall order. A large-scale cyberattack could quickly undo any economic upside that AI adoption had promised.

Read more: Low Chinese Demand for Foreign Oil Keeping Prices Low