Balance Confidence and Humility

What is the best approach?

Should you project confidence, humility, or a combination?

While confidence assures clients of your competence, humility ensures you remain adaptable and open to new information. Striking the right balance can significantly impact your success.

Pros of confidence

Client trust: Confidence is essential because it directly influences how clients perceive your competence. A confident advisor inspires trust, critical in the client-advisor relationship.

Clients are entrusting you with their wealth and financial future. They need to feel assured that you are capable of handling that responsibility.

Decision-making: Confident advisors are decisive.

According to research on decision theory, confidence (coupled with a healthy dose of humility) boosts your ability to make decisions without being paralyzed by doubt or overwhelmed by options.

Professional reputation: Your confidence can have a ripple effect, boosting your reputation.

Peers, clients, and other professionals tend to respect and follow the lead of those who exhibit self-assuredness. This positive reputation can lead to more referrals, networking opportunities, and a broader client base.

Cons of confidence

Overconfidence and risk: Overconfidence can lead to poor decision-making and increased risk. You may become too sure of your predictions or models, ignoring red flags or alternate viewpoints that could prevent mistakes.

One study found overconfident investors:

• Were under-diversified;
• Incurred higher losses; and
• Were less inclined to seek financial advice.

Diminished client communication: Overconfidence can come across as arrogance or condescension, alienating clients. Overconfident advisors may become less willing to explain their decisions, assuming clients trust their expertise. This can erode the client-advisor relationship as clients feel disregarded or disrespected.

Resistance to new information: Unchecked confidence can lead to a closed mindset. An advisor might resist new information or strategies and miss opportunities to adapt and innovate, ultimately hindering their long-term success.

Pros of humility

Openness: Humility fosters a growth mindset. Advisors who exhibit humility are more likely to seek new information, stay updated on market trends, and learn from their peers. This adaptability makes them better equipped to navigate complex market conditions.

According to a study on effective leadership traits, humility leads to a higher willingness to collaborate, learn, and pivot strategies when necessary.

Build stronger client relationships: Humility can enhance the client relationship by fostering a sense of partnership rather than dominance. When you listen actively and respect your client’s input, it encourages open communication.

Clients are more likely to share their concerns, ask questions, and feel involved in decision-making, which can lead to more tailored and effective financial plans.

Mitigate risk: Humility helps you recognize the limits of your knowledge, making you more cautious. A humble advisor will likely seek second opinions or conduct further research before making a significant recommendation.

Cons of humility

Perception of weakness: While humility is generally viewed as a positive trait, there is a risk that it could be misinterpreted as indecisiveness or lack of expertise.

Clients may want their advisors to take the lead and make strong recommendations. If an advisor appears too humble, they might appear uncertain or lack the confidence to manage large portfolios or complex financial plans.

Delayed decision-making: While humility can prevent reckless decisions, it can also slow the decision-making process. An advisor who is overly cautious or seeks excessive peer validation may miss out on opportunities.

Underestimating value: Humble advisors might underestimate their expertise and value, leading to pricing their services too low.

Striking a balance: Confident humility

The most successful financial advisors balance confidence and humility – a concept known as "confident humility."

Confident humility combines self-assurance with the humility to recognize and admit your limitations. It allows you to balance confidence in your abilities while being open to learning from others.

This balance allows you to project confidence in your expertise while remaining open to feedback, learning, and adaptability.

According to leadership studies, confident humility enables leaders to acknowledge their strengths while recognizing areas for improvement, making them more effective.

Financial advisors with confident humility can:

• Project authority while making clients feel heard and respected;
• Make decisive recommendations while remaining cautious of overconfidence; and
• Adapt to new information without abandoning their core expertise.

Combining these traits can enhance your professional reputation, foster long-term client relationships, and make well-rounded, informed decisions that benefit your business and clients.

Dan coaches evidence-based financial advisors on how to convert more prospects into clients. His digital marketing firm is a leading provider of SEO, website design, branding, content marketing, and video production services to financial advisors worldwide.

---

A message from Advisor Perspectives and VettaFi: To learn more about this and other topics, check out some of our webcasts.

More Active Management Topics >