Simon Sinek: How to Deal With "Toxic" Team Members

A high-performing employee with low trust is a “toxic” team member, according to Simon Sinek. You are better off with someone who inspires high trust, even if they are just a mediocre performer. The challenge is helping those who lack it build the trust they need to succeed.

Sinek is a consultant, author, motivational speaker and has one of the 10 the most popular Ted talks ever, How Great Leaders Inspire Action. He was a keynote speaker at last week’s AICPA conference in Las Vegas.

He has served as an organizational consultant with the Navy Seals, an organization that demands top performance and flawless teamwork.

His work with the Seals led him to classify team members along the two dimensions of trust and performance:

High Performance

Low Trust

High Performance

High Trust

Low Performance

Low Trust

Low Performance

High Trust

While performance is easily defined in the context of one’s job performance, trust is more difficult. Sinek said trust equates to personal character – for example, whether someone will “have your back” when the chips are down and whether they exhibit humility, empathy and patience. “Those are the qualities we want in good leaders,” Sinek said, “as well as good teachers.”

Everyone wants employees in the top right quadrant and nobody wants those in the lower left. Those are the easy calls. The challenge are those in the upper left, what Sinek called the “toxic” team members who perform exceptionally well but can’t build trust among their colleagues. He said they are typically very easy to identify – Just ask who the a--holes are.

They are not necessarily bad people, he said. They may have lacked feedback or worked for organizations that actually incented that type of behavior.

“Don’t fire them,” he said, “coach them to learn the right skills and improve performance. A lot of them can really grow.