Global Conditions Portend a Catch-Down in America

Other than Japan, the correlation between the real GDP of the US and that of every nation and region shown has increased over the last ten years compared to the prior twelve-year period. Equally important, the relationship between the US economy and the European Union, OECD nations, and the rest of the world is incredibly high. Those three aggregates exclude the US in their computations.

The graph below further highlights the strong relationships that globalization has brought upon US economic activity.

Lastly, we created a multiple regression model to predict US real GDP based on the real GDP of the ten nations we highlighted in the prior graphs. Our model has an R-square of .886, denoting a significant statistical relationship.

The graph below compares the US real GDP versus the model's output. The difference between the US GDP and the model averages slightly less than half a percent annually and doesn't vary beyond +/- 1%.

The US economy is tied at the hip to the global economy and economies of leading developed economies. Very short-term divergences occur, but barring a change to the world trade order or another round of massive U.S. stimulus, it's improbable that recent divergences will last.

Note that the data for the following graphs is through 2023; thus, it does not include 2024. My discussion of economic divergence between the U.S. and other nations primarily pertains to more recent data.

Britain

Britain's real GDP, as shown below, courtesy of the BBC, has contracted for two months in a row. Furthermore, it has shown no growth since June.

Personal consumption is a contributor to weak U.K. growth. Per Bloomberg:

A big drag on the economy was consumer-facing services, where output tumbled 0.6%, including a 2% decline in pubs and restaurants. It suggests that households tightened their belts, possibly fearing a squeeze from the budget.

Consumer sentiment in Britain is poor. Its citizens are worried about above-average inflation and high interest rates. More recently, consumers appear to be pulling back due to increased proposed fiscal spending that will be funded with higher taxes and borrowing.

As with most nations, the fear of U.S. tariffs weighs on U.K. consumer and business sentiment.

Lastly, it is worth noting that Britain's real GDP growth in 2023 was a mere 0.10%. The nation has barely grown in two years!

Europe

The European Union faces challenges similar to those faced by Britain. Europe's economic powerhouse, Germany, saw its real GDP decline last year, and contraction will likely continue this year.

One large differentiator between paltry European growth and growth in the U.S. is in the fiscal response to the pandemic. The U.S. flooded its economy with stimulus during and well after the initial sting of the pandemic.

Consumers were provided with funds and many other financial benefits. Meanwhile, the CHIPS Act fed infrastructure and manufacturing projects, further bolstering growth. Although the European Union and its nations also stimulated economic activity, the amounts were not comparable to those spent by the U.S. Per the Atlantic:

The UK and Germany spent more than $500 billion. France spent $235 billion, Italy $216 billion. But the United States was in a league of its own, spending an astonishing $5 trillion on pandemic relief. That's more, even in today's dollars, than America spent on the New Deal and World War II combined—and, crucially, it's more than double what most European countries spent on pandemic relief relative to the sizes of their respective economies.

Further, consider that Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the impact it has on energy prices is also to blame for sluggish growth, along with a host of other political and social factors.

China

Before the financial crisis, China had grown its economy by 10-15% yearly. While remarkable, it was unsustainable. Since then, growth has slowed substantially. However, it remains high compared to most developed nations. From 2020 to 2023, its real GDP growth was a relatively low 4.1%. It is expected to remain below 5% for the remainder of this year and during next year.

The nation is dealing with a credit hangover following decades of significant economic growth driven partly by massive infrastructure investment. Vacant cities and properties across China are leading to a decline in real estate activity, which once accounted for a significant portion of GDP. Construction and related industries have been negatively impacted, as has consumer sentiment.

Simultaneously, the country has a shrinking workforce and an aging population. Moreover, it faces weaker global export demand amid ongoing geopolitical tensions, particularly with the U.S. Trade restrictions and the post-pandemic redirection of global supply chains away from China manufacturing have negatively impacted key industrial sectors. Lastly, business confidence is eroding due to recent government policies, including regulatory crackdowns on tech firms and mixed signals on private-sector stimulus.

High levels of corporate debt and local government borrowing have further limited fiscal flexibility, making the government's recent spate of stimulus packages much less effective than prior stimulus. China's bond investors are taking notice. As shown below, its ten-year sovereign bond yield is now below 2%, the lowest in history.

China, once the world's marginal driver of economic growth, is exporting its economic slowdown across the globe.

Canada

I shared the following paragraph and graph from my recent Commentary on Canada:

On Wednesday, the Bank of Canada cut its key benchmark rate by 50bps. They have now cut by 150 bps in 2024, compared to what will likely be 100 bps for the Fed after next week's meeting. Unlike the Fed, Canada's central bank is fighting off a recession. Canadian real GDP for the last four quarters has been below 1%. Its unemployment rate troughed in January 2022 at a fifty-year low of 4.9%. However, since then, it has risen steadily to 6.8%. The Canadian dollar has been trading at its lowest levels compared to the US dollar since 2016 (excluding the pandemic).

We should pay attention because the US economy and Canada are extremely closely linked despite being different. The biggest differentiator is that Canada's economy relies much more heavily on commodities and manufacturing, while the US is more service-sector-oriented. Despite the differences, there has been a historically tight economic relationship between Canada and the US, as shown below.

High interest rates and sluggish oil prices weigh on Canada's economic growth. Unlike China, they are experiencing population growth. However, its growth masks economic weakness. Per The Fraser Institute:

Canada's recent growth record has received so much attention because it is, quite simply, abysmal. One recent analysis noted that due to weak total growth accompanied by a surging population, Canada has actually been in a "per capita" recession for some time. Per-person GDP has declined by 3.4 percent in inflation-adjusted terms between the second quarter of 2022 and the final quarter of 2023.

Summary

I could summarize economic conditions in other developed countries, and, in almost all cases, I would provide you with themes similar to those we share above. The takeaway is not necessarily the particulars of each country and region, but rather the recent rare economic growth divergence between the U.S. and the world.

The enormous pandemic and post-pandemic stimulus by the U.S. government is a key factor explaining the difference. The U.S. provided more stimulus on a GDP basis than all major developed economies. The stimulus was in the form of emergency payments, which had limited duration benefits. However, it also came in longer-lasting forms, like the CHIPS Act and loan forgiveness programs, which continues to bolster growth.

Indeed, significant federal deficit spending has helped offset much higher interest rates and stubborn inflation. Consumer confidence remains weary, but consumers continue to spend as the labor markets are relatively healthy. While all may seem well, I am growing concerned that headwinds to growth, including the global economy and high interest rates, will weigh on the U.S. economy.

As I wrote earlier, "Very short-term divergences occur, but barring a change to the world trade order or another round of massive U.S. stimulus, it's improbable that recent divergences will last."

It's more likely the U.S. economy will catch down to the global economy!

Michael Lebowitz is a portfolio manager with RIA Avisors and author for Real Investment Advice. For more information, contact him at [email protected] or 301.466.1204.

Join RIA Advisors and elevate your career within a deeply experienced team focused on innovation. Our collaborative environment is built on a foundation of advanced technology and effective investment models, designed to enhance your ability to serve clients and grow your practice. Benefit from a supportive culture that encourages professional development and fosters a forward-thinking approach. By joining our team, you’ll be part of a group dedicated to excellence and continuous improvement, empowering you to focus on building meaningful client relationships and pursuing your business ambitions. Discover the advantages of working with our accomplished advisory team by starting your conversation today.

---

A message from Advisor Perspectives and VettaFi: To learn more about this and other topics, check out some of our webcasts.

More Energy Topics >