Home | Asset Allocation | Most Popular Mutual Funds | Advisor Commentaries | Subscribe | About Us | About the Data | Archives | Advertise
 


Q4 Performance among the Most Popular Funds
in the Advisor Perspectives Universe
Email Article   Display as PDF

During the last nine months of 2007, actively managed foreign equity mutual funds in the Advisor Perspectives universe significantly outperformed their benchmarks.  However, actively managed funds in the three other categories (US equities, taxable bonds, and municipal bonds) underperformed their benchmarks.

 

 

 

 

The results are summarized in the table below:

 

Average Return

Average
Return of Benchmark

Benchmark

# of Funds
Outperforming
Benchmark

US Equities

3.29%

4.73%

SPY

10 of 25

Foreign Equities

14.26%

6.64%

EFA

17 of 25

Taxable Bonds

3.11%

5.11%

AGG

9 of 25

Muni Bonds

1.76%

2.76%

Lehman Muni Index

10 of 25

Previous versions of this study were done at the end of Q2 of 2007 and at the end of Q3 of 2007.

Detailed Findings

The study examined the top 25 actively managed mutual funds among the most popular mutual funds in the four categories noted above.  The significant findings are:

  • US Equities:  The average return across the top 25 funds was 3.29%, underperforming the S&P 500 (as measured by the SPY ETF) by 1.44%.  Of the 25 funds, 11 outperformed the S&P 500.  When measured against their secondary (style-box specific) benchmarks, the funds underperformed the S&P 500 by 1.41%, with 10 of 25 funds outperforming their secondary benchmarks.  Five funds outperformed the S&P in all three quarters – The Growth Fund of America (AGTHX), the Victory Diversified Stock Fund (SRVEX), the Fidelity Contrafund (FCNTX), the Marsico 21st Century Fund (MXXIX), and the T. Rowe Price Mid Cap Growth Fund (PAMCX).  The Growth Fund of America was also the most popular US equity fund.  The Fidelity Contrafund, the sixth most popular fund, had the largest outperformance relative to the S&P 500 (13.38%) and the largest outperformance relative to its secondary benchmark (7.74%).  The worst performing fund was the Fidelity Real Estate Investment Fund, underperforming the S&P 500 by 28.93%.
  • Foreign Equities:  The average return across the top 25 funds was 14.26%, outperforming the EFA ETF by 7.62%.  Of the 25 funds, 17 outperformed the EFA, and 12 funds outperformed the EFA in each of the three quarters.  Three of the top four performing funds were emerging market funds - the Fidelity Emerging Markets Fund (FEMKX – 39.95%), the SSGA Emerging Markets Fund (SSEMX – 37.16%), the Matthews Pacific Tiger International Fund (MAPTX – 34.63%), and the Harding Loevner Emerging Markets Fund (HLEMX – 34.26%).   These funds also outperformed the emerging markets EEM ETF, which returned 31.90% over the nine month time period.  The worst performing fund was the Oakmark International Small Cap Fund, which returned -13.36% over the three quarters, and was also the only foreign equity fund to lose money over this period.
  • Taxable Bonds:  The average return across the top 25 funds was 3.11%, underperforming the Lehman Aggregate Bond ETF (AGG) by 2.01%.  Of the top 25 funds, nine outperformed the AGG, and no fund outperformed the AGG in all three quarters.  The top three taxable funds are all PIMCO funds, and all outperformed the AGG – the PIMCO Total Return Fund (PTTAX – 6.88%), the PIMCO Low Duration Fund (PTLAX – 5.84%), and the PIMC Total Return Administrative Fund (PTRAX – 7.05%).  The worst performing fund (also the fifth most popular fund) was the Schwab Yield Plus Fund, which lost 2.51%, and was one of four funds to lose money over the period.
  • Municipal Bonds:  The average return across the top 25 funds was 1.76%, underperforming the Lehman Muni Bond Index by .99%.  (There is no ETF with sufficiently long performance history for municipal bonds, so we use this index for benchmark comparisons.)  Of the 25 funds, 10 outperformed the Lehman Muni Bond Index.  Only one fund (the JP Morgan New York Tax Free Fund – JNYIX) outperformed the index in all three quarters.  The top performing fund (and second most popular fund) was the Vanguard Limited Term Tax Exempt Fund (VMLTX – 3.43%), followed closely by the Thornburg Investors Trust Limit Term Fund (LTMIX – 3.35%), the JP Morgan Fund Tax Free Fund (JNYIX – 3.35%), and the Sanford Bernstein Diversified Municipals Fund (SNDPX – 3.22%).  The worst performing fund, and one of only two funds to lose money, was the Nuveen High Yield Municipals Bond Fund (ACTHX - -6.17%).

Background and Methodology

The Advisor Perspectives universe tracks the assets of high- and ultra-high net worth investors whose assets are managed by Registered Investment Advisors.  The size of the universe is approximately $50 billion and the average account size is approximately $900,000.  However, 94% of the assets are concentrated in a group of accounts with an average account size of approximately $4 million, so data from the universe is biased by this demographic, and therefore represents the investment decisions of ultra-high net worth investors.

The most popular mutual funds are determined based on the AUM (assets under management) for each fund within the Advisor Perspectives universe.  The inception of the Advisor Perspectives service was in Q1 of 2007.  The first complete calendar quarter of data was Q2 of 2007, which is why this study examines the last three quarters of 2007.

The funds used in this study were the most popular funds as of March 31, 2007.  Only actively managed funds were considered; index funds, enhanced index funds, and ETFs were not included in this study.

To calculate the AUM of each fund, assets are consolidated across all share classes held in the Advisor Perspectives universe.  For this study, performance data was obtained for the share class most appropriate for advisors (either a load-waived share class or an institutional share class).

Performance data and style-box classifications were obtained from Morningstar.

Detailed data is presented in the four tables below.

US Equities

(LC = Large Cap; MC = Mid Cap; SC = Small Cap)
(G = Growth; B = Blend; V = Value)

 

 

 

2007 Performance

 

 

 

Ticker

Fund

Style

Q2

Q3

Q4

2007
9 Mos.

Perf.
v.
SPY

Perf.
v.
Scndry
Index

AGTHX.lw

GROWTH OF AMERICA FUND

LC/G

7.71

4.43

-2.72

9.42

4.69

-0.95

DODGX

DODGE AND COX STOCK FUND

LC/B

5.41

-1.92

-4.78

-1.56

-6.29

-6.29

FRIAX

FRANKLIN TEMPLETON CUSTODIAN
INCOME FUND

LC/B

2.47

1.39

-2.10

1.71

-3.02

-3.02

SRVEX.lw

VICTORY DIVERSIFIED STOCK FUND

LC/G

9.10

3.43

-1.64

10.99

6.26

0.62

FEQIX

FIDELITY EQUITY INCOME FUND

LC/B

7.31

-0.41

-6.12

0.33

-4.40

-4.40

FCNTX

FIDELITY CONTRAFUND FUND

LC/G

7.50

7.16

2.53

18.11

13.38

7.74

ABALX.lw

BALANCED FUND

LC/G

5.02

2.77

-1.97

5.80

1.07

-4.57

JENIX

JENSEN FUND

LC/G

5.13

3.41

0.06

8.78

4.05

-1.59

TAVFX

THIRD AVENUE VALUE FUND

MC/B

4.45

2.97

-4.70

2.50

-2.24

1.45

FMCSX

FIDELITY MID CAP STOCK FUND

MC/G

7.67

-0.19

-5.54

1.51

-3.22

-5.49

UMBIX

EXCELSIOR VALUE AND RESTRUCTURING
FUND

LC/V

10.05

-1.55

-1.43

6.79

2.06

8.29

FRESX

FIDELITY REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT FUND

LC/B

-11.14

0.59

-15.19

-24.19

-28.93

-28.93

MXXIX

MARSICO 21ST CENTURY FUND

LC/G

10.32

6.36

0.59

18.03

13.29

7.65

PRWCX

TROWEPRICE CAPITAL APPRECIATION
FUND

LC/B

5.83

-1.08

-1.59

3.02

-1.71

-1.71

FLMVX

JP MORGAN MID CAP VALUE FUND

MC/V

4.22

-1.21

-3.45

-0.59

-5.33

5.51

AWSHX.lw

WASHINGTON MUTUAL FUND

LC/B

6.71

1.80

-5.18

3.00

-1.73

-1.73

FDCAX

FIDELITY CAPITAL APPRECIATION FUND

LC/B

7.50

3.09

-5.73

4.47

-0.26

-0.26

FDVLX

FIDELITY VALUE FUND

MC/V

6.35

-1.60

-6.78

-2.45

-7.18

3.66

MPMCX

MELLON MID CAP STOCK FUND

MC/G

7.33

0.41

-0.06

7.71

2.97

0.70

DNVYX

DAVIS NEW YORK VENTURE FUND

LC/B

6.56

-0.26

-1.98

4.18

-0.56

-0.56

PAMCX

TROWEPRICE MID CAP GROWTH FUND

MC/G

11.48

3.38

-1.29

13.76

9.03

6.76

AIVSX.lw

INVESTMENT COMPANY OF AMERICAN
FUND

LC/B

6.91

2.50

-4.33

4.84

0.10

0.10

HWLAX.lw

HOTCHKIS AND WILEY LARGE CAP VALUE
FUND

LC/V

3.80

-7.37

-8.37

-11.90

-16.63

-10.41

LLPFX

LONGLEAF PARTNERS FUND

LC/B

8.08

-1.45

-8.55

-2.59

-7.33

-7.33

FLPSX

FIDELITY LOW PRICED STOCK FUND

MC/B

6.34

-2.57

-2.94

0.56

-4.17

-0.48

 

Average

 

6.08

0.96

-3.73

3.29

-1.44

-1.41

SPY

SPDRs

LC/B

6.24

2.01

-3.36

4.73

 

 

IWF

iShares Russell 1000 Growth Index

LC/G

6.81

4.16

-0.79

10.37

 

 

IWD

iShares Russell 1000 Value Index

LC/V

4.88

-0.28

-5.81

-1.49

 

 

IWP

iShares Russell Midcap Growth Index

MC/G

6.68

2.08

-1.74

7.00

 

 

IWR

iShares Russell Midcap Index

MC/B

5.25

-0.42

-3.59

1.05

 

 

IWS

iShares Russell Midcap Value Index

MC/V

3.62

-3.58

-6.02

-6.10

 

 

Foreign Equities

(LC = Large Cap; MC = Mid Cap; SC = Small Cap)
(G = Growth; B = Blend; V = Value)

 

 

 

2007 Performance

 

 

Ticker

Fund

Style

Q2

Q3

Q4

2007
9 mo

Perf. v. EFA

DODFX

DODGE AND COX INTERNATIONAL STOCK FUND

LC/B

6.61

0.43

-0.65

6.37

-0.27

AEPGX.lw

AMERICAN EUROPACIFIC GROWTH FUND

LC/B

8.43

5.23

1.29

15.57

8.93

BJBIX

JULIUS BAER INTERNATIONAL EQUITY FUND

LC/B

8.82

1.97

0.88

11.94

5.30

MACSX

MATTHEWS ASIAN GROWTH AND INCOME FUND

LC/V

8.89

5.67

3.10

18.63

11.99

SGOVX.lw

FIRST EAGLE SOGEN OVERSEAS FUND

LC/B

3.71

1.55

-1.19

4.06

-2.57

FDIVX

FIDELITY DIVERSIFIED INTERNATIONAL FUND

LC/B

7.77

4.87

-0.41

12.56

5.92

SGENX.lw

FIRST EAGLE SOGEN GLOBAL FUND

LC/B

4.48

1.37

1.36

7.35

0.71

ARTIX

ARTISAN INTERNATIONAL FUND

LC/B

5.53

5.34

2.84

14.32

7.68

MAPTX

MATTHEWS PACIFIC TIGER INTERNATIONAL FUND

LC/B

16.69

10.34

4.56

34.63

27.99

JFEIX

JP MORGAN INTREPID EUROPEAN FUND

LC/B

9.23

1.91

-1.41

9.75

3.11

OAKEX

OAKMARK INTERNATIONAL SMALL CAP FUND

SC/V

2.52

-6.60

-9.52

-13.36

-20.00

SNIVX

SANFORD C BERNSTEIN BERNSTEIN TAX MANAGED
INTERNATIONAL VALUE FUND

LC/B

6.63

2.45

-4.59

4.23

-2.41

TBGVX

TWEEDY BROWNE GLOBAL VALUE FUND

LC/B

5.94

-0.64

-2.20

2.95

-3.69

FEMKX

FIDELITY EMERGING MARKETS FUND

LC/B

15.59

13.62

6.56

39.95

33.31

TGVAX.lw

THORNBURG INTERNATIONAL VALUE FUND

LC/B

12.23

10.20

0.16

23.88

17.24

NIIVX

ING INTERNATIONAL VALUE FUND

LC/B

4.87

-0.35

-1.11

3.34

-3.30

SSEMX

SSGA EMERGING MARKETS FUND

LC/B

15.70

15.69

2.47

37.16

30.52

HAINX

HARBOR INTERNATIONAL FUND

LC/B

10.29

5.95

1.12

18.16

11.52

NAIGX.lw

NUVEEN TRADEWINDS INTERNATIONAL VALUE FUND

LC/B

5.99

4.54

-1.96

8.63

1.99

ANWPX.lw

NEW PERSPECTIVE FUND

LC/B

8.49

5.14

0.00

14.07

7.43

PRIDX

TROWEPRICE INTERNATIONAL DISCOVERY FUND

MC/B

9.01

2.80

-1.50

10.38

3.74

FDVAX.lw

FIDELITY ADVISORS DIVERSIFIED INTERNATIONAL
FUND

LC/B

6.23

1.70

-2.70

5.12

-1.52

HLEMX

HARDING LOEVNER EMERGING MARKETS FUND

LC/B

12.80

12.97

5.36

34.26

27.62

FICDX

FIDELITY CANADA FUND

LC/B

16.21

9.53

1.78

29.55

22.91

SEITX

SEI INTERNATIONAL EQUITY FUND

LC/B

7.05

0.56

-4.34

2.98

-3.66

 

Average

 

8.79

4.65

0.00

14.26

7.62

EFA

iShares MSCI EAFE Index

 

6.49

2.09

-1.91

6.64

 

 

Taxable Bonds

(ST = Short Term; MT = Medium Term; LT = Long Term)
(IG = Investment Grade; MG = Mid Grade)

 

 

 

2007 Performance

 

 

Ticker

Fund

Style

Q2

Q3

Q4

2007
9 mo

Perf. v. AGG

PTTAX.lw

PIMCO TOTAL RETURN FUND

MT/IG

-1.44

4.47

3.80

6.88

1.76

PTLAX.lw

PIMCO LOW DURATION FUND

ST/IG

-0.42

3.60

2.59

5.84

0.72

PTRAX

PIMCO TOTAL RETURN ADMINISTRATIVE FUND

MT/IG

-1.39

4.52

3.86

7.05

1.93

DODIX

DODGE AND COX INCOME FUND

MT/IG

-0.24

2.10

1.32

3.20

-1.92

SWYPX

SCHWAB YIELD PLUS FUND

ST/MG

1.11

-1.04

-2.57

-2.51

-7.63

JBSEX

JP MORGAN BOND FUND

MT/IG

-0.44

0.07

0.14

-0.23

-5.35

TRLVX

SEI INSTITUTIONAL MANAGED CORE FIXED INCOME
FUND

MT/IG

-0.88

1.98

1.36

2.46

-2.66

LSBDX

LOOMIS SAYLES I BOND FUND

LT/MG

1.86

3.23

1.20

6.41

1.30

SDFIX

STANDISH FIXED INCOME FUND

MT/IG

-0.71

1.09

1.64

2.02

-3.10

VFSTX

VANGUARD SHORT TERM INVESTMENT GRADE FUND

ST/IG

0.46

1.91

1.81

4.23

-0.88

ABNDX

BOND OF AMERICAN FUND

MT/MG

-0.26

1.74

0.36

1.84

-3.27

FBNDX

FIDELITY INVESTMENT GRADE BOND FUND

MT/IG

-0.69

1.00

0.93

1.24

-3.88

PHDAX.lw

PIMCO HIGH YIELD FUND

MT/MG

-0.02

0.95

0.20

1.13

-3.98

AHITX.lw

AMERICAN HIGH INCOME TRUST FUND

MT/MG

0.98

-0.24

-1.59

-0.86

-5.98

FSICX

FIDELITY STRATEGIC INCOME FUND

MT/MG

0.10

2.26

1.31

3.70

-1.41

NEFZX.lw

LOOMIS SAYLES STRATEGIC INCOME TRUST II
FUND

LT/MG

1.90

2.85

0.71

5.55

0.43

VFIIX

VANGUARD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MORTGAGE
ASSOCIATION FUND

MT/IG

-0.66

2.95

3.29

5.64

0.52

OHYAX.lw

JP MORGAN HIGH YIELD BOND FUND

MT/MG

-0.33

0.46

-1.15

-1.02

-6.14

DFIHX

DFA ONE YEAR FIXED INCOME FUND

ST/IG

1.28

1.20

1.26

3.79

-1.33

HABDX

HARBOR BOND FUND

MT/IG

-1.33

4.37

3.96

7.06

1.95

FAGIX

FIDELITY CAPITAL AND INCOME FUND

MT/MG

2.31

-0.49

-1.14

0.65

-4.47

FSHBX

FIDELITY SHORT TERM BOND FUND

ST/IG

0.28

0.20

0.05

0.53

-4.58

PARRX

PIMCO REAL RETURN FUND

LT/IG

-1.44

4.77

5.17

8.60

3.49

EABLX

EATON VANCE FLOATING RATE FUND

MT/IG

1.32

-1.39

-0.10

-0.19

-5.30

OMBIX

JP MORGAN MORTGAGE BACKED SECURITIES FUND

MT/IG

-0.41

2.81

2.22

4.66

-0.45

 

Average

 

0.04

1.81

1.23

3.11

-2.01

AGG

iShares Lehman Aggregate Bond

 

-0.63

2.71

2.99

5.11

 

Municipal Bonds

(ST = Short Term; MT = Medium Term; LT = Long Term)
(IG = Investment Grade; MG = Mid Grade)

 

 

 

2007 Performance

 

 

Ticker

Fund

Style

Q2

Q3

Q4

2007
9 mo

Perf. v.
Lehman
Bond Index

VSITX

JP MORGAN INTERMEDIATE TAX FREE FUND

MT/IG

-0.47

2.11

1.43

3.08

0.33

VMLTX

VANGUARD LIMITED TERM TAX EXEMPT FUND

ST/IG

0.21

1.74

1.45

3.43

0.67

NHMAX.lw

NUVEEN HIGH YIELD MUNICIPALS BOND FUND

LT/MG

-0.67

-2.30

-3.31

-6.17

-8.92

ACTHX.lw

VANKAMPEN HIGH YIELD MUNICIPALS FUND

LT/MG

-0.09

-1.08

-1.30

-2.45

-5.21

VWITX

VANGUARD INTERMEDIATE TERM TAX EXEMPT
FUND

MT/IG

-0.56

1.74

1.50

2.69

-0.07

SNDPX

SANFORD BERNSTEIN DIVERSIFIED MUNICIPALS
FUND

MT/IG

-0.39

2.16

1.43

3.22

0.46

LTMIX

THORNBURG INVESTORS TRUST LIMITED TERM
MUNICIPALS FUND

MT/IG

0.03

1.95

1.34

3.35

0.59

VMPAX.lw

EVERGREEN STRATEGIC MUNICIPALS BOND FUND

LT/IG

0.60

0.82

0.85

2.29

-0.47

VNYTX

VANGUARD NEW YORK LONG TERM TAX EXEMPT
FUND

MT/IG

-0.87

1.46

1.18

1.76

-0.99

VWSTX

VANGUARD SHORT TERM TAX EXEMPT FUND

ST/IG

0.66

1.26

1.31

3.26

0.51

VMATX

VANGUARD MASSACHUSETTS TAX EXEMPT FUND

MT/IG

-0.93

1.67

1.54

2.28

-0.48

SNNYX

SANFORD BERNSTEIN NEW YORK MUNICIPALS
FUND

MT/IG

-0.31

2.19

1.30

3.20

0.44

HLTAX

JP MORGAN MUNICIPALS INCOME FUND

LT/IG

-0.52

2.09

1.14

2.72

-0.04

SEIMX

SEI TAX EXEMPT TRUST INTERMEDIATE
MUNICIPALS FUND

MT/IG

-0.66

1.58

1.01

1.93

-0.83

SZMAX.lw

DWS TAX FREE TRUST INTERMEDIATE TAX AMT
FREE FUND

MT/IG

-0.49

2.16

1.42

3.10

0.35

VCADX

VANGUARD CALIFORNIA INTERMEDIATE TERM
TAX EXEMPT FUND

MT/IG

-0.46

1.67

1.12

2.34

-0.42

VWAHX

VANGUARD HIGH YIELD TAX EXEMPT FUND

MT/MG

-0.62

0.81

0.51

0.70

-2.06

SCMBX

DWS MUNICIPALS TRUST MANAGED MUNICIPALS
BOND FUND

MT/IG

-0.55

2.18

1.04

2.67

-0.08

JNYIX

JP MORGAN NEW YORK TAX FREE BOND FUND

MT/IG

-0.43

2.17

1.59

3.35

0.59

KCTAX.lw

DWS STATE TAX FREE INCOME CALIFORNIA TAX
FREE INCOME
FUND

MT/IG

-0.71

2.00

0.78

2.07

-0.69

ETCTX.lw

EATON VANCE CONNECTICUT MUNICIPALS FUND

LT/IG

-0.86

1.54

0.19

0.86

-1.90

MPMFX

MORGAN STANLEY INSTITUTIONAL MUNICIPALS
FUND

MT/MG

-0.24

1.82

0.73

2.32

-0.44

LHIAX.lw

COLUMBIA SERIES TRUST I HIGH YIELD
MUNICIPALS FUND

LT/MG

-0.47

-0.45

-1.97

-2.87

-5.63

FLTMX

FIDELITY SPARTAN INTERMEDIATE MUNICIPALS
INCOME FUND

MT/IG

-0.45

2.11

1.52

3.20

0.44

 

Average

 

-0.39

1.39

0.74

1.76

-0.99

 

Lehman Muni Bond Index

 

-0.60

1.82

1.53

2.76

 



Display article as PDF for printing
.

Would you like to send this article to a friend?

Remember, if you have a question or comment, send it to .


Contact Us
Website by the Boston Web Company