Gauging Investor Sentiment with Twitter: New Update
Advisor Perspectives welcomes guest contributions. The views presented here do not necessarily represent those of Advisor Perspectives.
The Downside Hedge Twitter sentiment indicator for the S&P 500 Index (SPX) is still on a consolidation warning. The previous warnings from this indicator have all resulted with SPX trading below the level of the warning even if sentiment diverged from price for several weeks. Of course, three instances don't make a valid sample set, but it shows potential.
Sentiment on a daily basis continues to show lackluster prints whether the market is up or down. This is happening while the intensity of tweets is falling. Opinions are drying up which suggests that traders are waiting before taking any significant action.
Smoothed sentiment is still showing a negative divergence, but is somewhat mirroring price. It moved back above zero, but won't clear its consolidation warning until it moves above the declining trend line. When sentiment follows price (instead of leading) it suggests that traders are simply reacting to the moves in the market rather than making trades based on their belief about future outcomes. This is a sign of indecision.
Twitter support and resistance coiled very tightly this week however it has a slight downside bias. There are only a few tweets calling for anything above 1600 on SPX. The 1600 level is being mentioned four times more than any other price point which suggests traders will need to see prices above this level before getting aggressive. Below the market, 1575, 1550, and 1535 are the most tweeted levels signaling that traders believe another trip lower is possible. There are some scattered tweets well below current prices at 1475 and 1500 which shows growing anticipation from a few bears. Overall it appears that traders are simply trading against 1550 and 1600 until they get more clarity.
Twitter sector sentiment flipped quickly this week. Last week every sector had negative sentiment (something we hadn't seen before). This week leading sectors gained support while defensive sectors lagged. Consumer discretionary stocks which have had strong gains this year are now showing the most negative sentiment. We thought last week's across the board negative sentiment meant a flight to safety. It now appears that it may simply be profit taking in the highest performing sectors this year. Although sector rotation this week was positive, it is very uncommon to see money flowing out of defensive stocks and into leading stocks near market highs. It makes us somewhat uncomfortable to see money managers removing risk from their portfolios by selling defensive stocks. It begs the question, "Where will money go if this market starts to decline?"
From a sentiment perspective we're seeing indecision with a negative bias for the market. Traders aren't targeting prices above 1600 on SPX, but have several target levels below. Daily sentiment is moving in a tight range while smoothed sentiment chases price. Profit taking is occurring in defensive sectors near a market high which increases instability. All of the above are cause for concern.
Note: I have created a download page so readers can load the sentiment indicator into their own chart packages. It's located here.
Note from dshort: Here is a YouTube video in which Blair gives an explanation of the indicator and examples of how he used it in his posts over the last several weeks.
For additional background information on this indicator, see Gauging Investor Sentiment with Twitter.
Blair Jensen at Downside Hedge tracks Twitter sentiment and provides hedging strategies for individual investors.